“ Came here for the first time in october.. love the fact that they were decorated for halloween because it's my favorite holiday. Came back every weekend in october, and was pleasantly surprised by their halloween costume party, and a live show by a very funny podcast. They have a great selection of beer on draft and I basically have tried everything on the menu and have never been disappointed. ”

“ The Firefly has quickly become our new favorite place! We were pleasantly surprised by how much we enjoy this bar--it's truly the best. We now go out of our way not! to make reservations so we can sit at the bar, which is the coziest and most beautiful space, reminiscent of something you'd see on TV. One thing that stood out is a sign stating they reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. While this is understandable, it does feel a bit unwelcoming. However, the atmosphere is warm, and the bartender is incredibly nice, which contributes significantly to our comfort and enjoyment. We sat at the tables and the waiter got a lot of things wrong last time so we're just gonna stick to the bar because the bartender is great. The pizzas are fantastic; we love the variety they offer, and the two different sizes make it very reasonable. The kick in the a** and the white pizza with fig are the best! The appetizers are also good . They do a special fire fries which is similar to smashed potato, the giant meatball which isnt really worth the money but its still yummy, the rice balls are much better than average and the arugula salad has a lot of taste with a not too sweet dressing and gorgonzola. I did notice I was charged for a side of aioli that I didn't receive, but that didn't dampen our experience. We love the drinks and the beers.! Overall, we had a blast and are looking forward to returning every week. We've already been three times and are headed back next week! ”

“ Best pizza I've ever had! Got the one with hot honey on it! Delicious! Service was fantastic and the decor and atmosphere is top notch ”

“ Great neighborhood place with a lovely patio and good pizza. We went on a Sunday afternoon and were seated quickly on the dog-friendly patio. The service was friendly and attentive. We had the spinach and mushroom rice balls, fries with lemon ricotta dip, a large Verrazano boy, and a large Saturday night fever minus the meat. Everything was fantastic! Lots of vegetarian options, or the ability to make things vegetarian (they also have plant-based meats for those who like them). ”

“ Cool place, great vibes. Loved seeing the history in pics along the walls. Came on a Sunday afternoon, not too busy. There was a wedding party so the dj was pretty good. Pizza was delish paired well with the arugula salad. I'd come back to try more on the menu. ”

“ Love the decor and vibe of this place. I was here in the past when it was Yellow Hook Grill. The waiter was attentive and kind. The pizza pies and calzone were delicious! Their dough was so good and their crust had the perfect crisp. I did not like their Brooklyn egg cream drink so they took it off the bill. It was basically just syrup. Other than that, everything was really good and would love to return. ”

“ Despite my having been here a few times already I've never gotten around to sitting down and composing my thoughts about The Brooklyn Firefly so I'm going to use a recent visit to resolve that. For many of the Bay Ridge lifers, this restaurant occupies the space that was formerly the home of the famed Lento's pizza. This space was known and loved for its thin-crust pizza. At the time, this was not a common thing but now you can get it in a lot of places. Lucky you. Thinking back to my time before this latest visit, I recall having half of a wonderful cheese pizza with another friend and a few cold beers. They have a full bar, but I am not really the biggest spirits person so a Budweiser or Coors Lite suits me fine unless I am on one of my not drinking months. That pizza was super tasty and didn't last long since we were both quite hungry. It's easy to eat four slices of this since its not as thick as most pizzas. Fast forward to this past Saturday I was out walking with a friend and we met up with others who were heading there for some cocktails and decided to join them to catch up. We decided to sit at the bar area in the front. Spatially speaking there is a lengthy outdoor dining area and several tables in the rear of the restaurant. They raved about the cocktails but I was not drinking this time around. I think one of them was called The Gelston and my friend had a Pumpkin beer. Eats were decided upon so we ordered up some Rice Balls (there are three to an order) and a pizza with half-spinach and half sausage. Good stuff for sure. There is a free WiFi signal so one can do their check-ins and foodie captures and shares across their networks. The prices are very reasonable and the staff quite friendly. I'll be coming back sometime in the future for sure. ”